تحديات التنظيم القانوني لتدخل الشخص الثالث أمام المحاكم الإدارية الفلسطينية: دراسة تحليلية مقارنة: CHALLENGES OF THE LEGAL REGULATION OF THIRD PARTY INTERVENTION BEFORE THE PALESTINIAN ADMINISTRATIVE COURTS: COMPARATIVE AND ANALYTICAL STUDY

Ahmad Ziad Ahmad Dabak

doi:10.33102/mjsl.vol12no1.473

Authors

Ahmad Ziad Ahmad Dabak Public Law Department, Arab American University, P.O Box 240 Jenin, Jenin Road, 13 Zababdeh, Palestine. https://orcid.org/0009-0000-7479-6070

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.33102/mjsl.vol12no1.473

Keywords:

Administrative Courts, Third Party Intervention, Mandatory Intervention, Voluntary Intervention, المحاكم الادارية, تدخل الشخص الثالث, التدخل الالزامي, التدخل الطوعي

Abstract

This research aims to study Legal Regulation of Third Party Intervention before the Palestinian Administrative Courts. by exploring legislative gaps in Articles 30 and 31 of the Decree-Law on Palestinian Administrative Courts, No. 41 of 2020, and seeks to enhance them to ensure justice, equality, and the protection of human rights and freedoms. The research employs a descriptive, analytical, and comparative approach to analyze and compare the legislative texts concerning third-party intervention before administrative courts in Palestinian law with those in the legal systems of comparable countries. Specifically, the research addresses the topics of mandatory and voluntary intervention, including their respective requirements and procedures. The research concludes that there are several gaps and ambiguities concerning the legal regulation of third-party intervention before administrative courts, which leads to inconsistencies in judicial opinions and practices regarding this issue. Therefore, the study recommends amending this legislation to enhance matters related to third-party intervention through the review of legal systems of comparable countries and learning from their experiences. in addition to establishing clear criteria to differentiate between types of intervention and evaluating their impact on the case, thereby supporting a deep understanding of legal practices and providing a framework in Palestinian administrative law.

ملخص البحث

يهدف هذا البحث إلى دراسة التنظيم القانوني لتدخل الشخص الثالث أمام المحاكم الإدارية الفلسطينية، مستكشفاً الثغرات التشريعية في المادتين (30) و (31) من القرار بقانون بشأن المحاكم الإدارية الفلسطيني رقم (41) لسنة 2020، ويسعى إلى تحسينها لضمان العدالة والمساواة وحماية حقوق الانسان وحرياته، ويستخدم البحث منهجاً وصفياً تحليلياً مقارناً لتحليل ومقارنة النصوص التشريعية المتعلقة بتدخل الشخص الثالث أمام لمحاكم الإدارية في التشريع الفلسطيني مع النظم القانونية للمحاكم الإدارية في الدول المقارنة، من حيث تناول موضوعات التدخل الإلزامي والتدخل الطوعي، بما في ذلك شروطهما وإجراءاتهما، وتوصل البحث إلى وجود العديد من الثغرات والتساؤلات المتعلقة بالتنظيم القانوني لتدخل الشخص الثالث أمام المحاكم الإدارية، الأمر الذي يؤدي إلى وجود اختلافات في الآراء والممارسات القضائية بشأن هذا الموضوع، لذلك يوصي البحث بتعديل هذا التشريع لتحسين المسائل المتعلقة بتدخل الشخص الثالث من خلال مراجعة نظم دول مقارنة والتعلم من تجاربها، إلى جانب وضع معايير واضحة للتمييز بين أنواع التدخل وتقييم تأثيرها على الدعوى، دعمًا لفهم عميق للممارسات القانونية وتوفير إطار مرجعي في القانون الإداري الفلسطيني.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abu Al-Wafa, A. (1990). Civil and commercial pleadings (15th ed.). Knowledge Establishment.

Abu Samhadaneh, A. A. (2014). Administrative litigation procedures (1st ed.). National Center for Legal Publications.

Ado, A. (2016). The procedural role of the French administrative judge in the administrative litigation. Kuwait University Law Journal, 1, 453-485.

Ahmed, A. A., & Ahmed, I. S. (2018). Compensation Lawsuit in Light of the Opinions of Jurists, Legislation, and Judicial Rulings (1st ed.). Dar Al-Adalah Publishing and Distribution.

Ahmed, I. S., & Al-Tabakh, S. A. (2014). Explanation of the State Council Law (1st ed.). Nas Printing Company.

Ahmed, M. A. Z. (2022). Legal system for incidental applications before administrative justice. Journal of Economic and Legal Sciences, Faculty of Law, Ain Shams University, 2(64), 103-260.

Al-Bakri, M. A. (2016). The plea of not accepting the lawsuit (1st ed.). Dar Mahmoud Publishing.

Al-Bakri, M. A. (2018-2019a). Commentary on the Law of Expropriation for Public Benefit (1st ed.). Dar Mahmoud Publishing and Distribution.

Al-Bakri, M. A. (2018-2019b). Commentary on the laws of judicial fees (7th ed.). Dar Mahmoud Publishing.

Al-Bakri, M. A. (2021-2022). Defenses in the Law of Proceedings in light of Jurisprudence and Judiciary (Vol. 3). Dar Mahmoud Publishing and Distribution.

Al-Essa, T. Y. A., & Sabbahin, Y. Y. (2017). Intervention in the dispute. Journal of Sharia and Law Sciences, 44(3), 201-215.

Al-Essa, T.Y.A., & Sabahin, S.Y. (2017). Intervention in litigation. Journal of Shari'a and Law Sciences, 44(3), 201-215.

Al-Husamuti, H. O. A. (2018). The international administrative judiciary in the International Labor Organization. The Arab Center for Scientific Studies, Research, Publishing, and Distribution.

Al-Issa, M. A. K. (2011). The Supreme Administrative Court in the system of the Saudi Bureau of Grievances (1st ed.). Law and Economy Library.

Aliya, I. S. (2021). Appeal of the third party in the administrative judgment. Al-Baath University Journal, 43(18), 93-152.

Al-Khalaileh, M. A. (2013). Aspects of the independence of administrative litigation procedures from civil lawsuit procedures in Jordanian law. Journal of Sharia and Law Sciences, 40(1), 27-43.

Al-Lahibi, A. S. (2019). Appeals in Administrative Judgments (1st ed.). Alexandria: Dar Al-Jami'a Al-Jadida.

Al-Saudi, O. M. (2022). The authority of the sharia court in modifying the scope of the lawsuit. Dar Al-Yazouri Scientific.

Al-Shahrani, A.S. (2014). Dates and related judgments, the system of litigation and procedures before administrative courts. Riyadh: Law and Economy Library.

Al-Tabakh, S. (2015). Administrative mediation in the Encyclopedia of Administrative Responsibility. Nas Printing Company.

Al-Tahir, K. K. (2009). Administrative Judiciary (1st ed.). Riyadh: Law and Economy Library.

Al-Tamawi, S. M. (1978). The theory of arbitrariness in the use of power: Deviation by authority. Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi.

Al-Zubaidi, M. A. A. (2018). The legal system for the expiration of the administrative lawsuit without a substantive judgment. Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution.

Al-Zuhairi, A. H. A. (2017). Oversight of the constitutionality of systems and administrative decisions under the Constitution of the Republic of Iraq of 2005 (1st ed.). Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution.

Baalousha, S.A. (2018). Litigation procedures before the administrative judiciary (1st ed.). Center for Arab Studies.

El-Garf, T. (1984). Judicial control of public administration actions. Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya.

Hassanin, A.N.A. (2018). Intervention and admission in arbitration in the light of jurisprudential opinions and judicial rulings and its impact on the principle of confidentiality. Al-Wadi International University Journal for Legal Studies, 3, 313-405.

Hassanin, A.N.A. (2020). Intervention and introduction in arbitration dispute. Dar Al-Taaleem Al-Jamai.

Herja, M. M. (2016). Objections and incidental demands in the law of civil and commercial pleadings. Dar Mahmoud Publishing, Cairo.

Ibn Ashour, A. (2006). The administrative judiciary and the jurisprudence of administrative litigation (3rd ed.). University Publishing Center, No place of publication.

Ibrahim, M.A. (2018). Legal regulation of non-original parties in administrative litigation: a jurisprudential and judicial comparative study in applications and appeals of the non-original parties in administrative litigation. Alexandria University Faculty of Law Journal for Legal and Economic Research, 1(4), 4-120.

Ismail, K.A.S. (2016a). Procedures for filing a lawsuit before the administrative and ordinary judiciary. (1st ed.). Dar Mahmoud.

Ismail, K.A.S. (2016b). The administrative lawsuit. (1st ed.). Dar Mahmoud, Cairo.

Ismail, M.A.S. (n.d.). Council of State judiciary and forms of administrative lawsuits and their procedures. Dar Muhammad for Publishing and Distribution.

Jordanian Administrative Court. (2022). Ruling number 396/2022 in the case number 386/2022. Unpublished.

Legifrance. (2019). “Conseil d'État, 9ème - 10ème chambres réunies, 09/10/2019, 430538”. Republique Francaise. https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/ceta/id/CETATEXT000039210278?page=1&pageSize=10&query=N°430538%2C+431689.&searchField=ALL&searchType=ALL&sortValue=DATE_DESC&tab_selection=cetat

Mansoura, M. M. T. (2006). Administrative litigation procedures [Doctoral dissertation, Ain Shams University].

Masoud, M. A. H. (2009). Problems of litigation procedures before the administrative judiciary (The general theory of administrative lawsuit from its establishment until the judgment in it). Knowledge Establishment.

Nasreen, O.F., & Tayeb, Q. (2019). Intervention and introduction in civil matter [Master's thesis, Abderrahmane Mira University, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences].

Qaduri, I. (2019). The incidental applications and their impact on the course of the lawsuit. The Researcher Journal for Legal and Judicial Studies, 10, 153-181.

Radi, M. B. (2017). The general rules in determining the date of filing a cancellation lawsuit. The Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution.

Sabeg, H., & Shetour, J. (2018/2019). Litigation in the administrative matter before the Council of State [Doctoral dissertation, Mohammed Khider University of Biskra - Faculty of Law and Political Science].

Saeed, D.A. & Rasool, B.A. (2020). Privacy of lawsuit procedures in the administrative judiciary. Landmarks Journal of Legal and Political Studies, 4(2), 390-418.

Sayed, A. F. M. (2020). The specificity of judicial procedures before the State Council in the light of jurisprudence opinions and judicial rulings [Doctoral dissertation, Faculty of Law, Cairo University].

Shahata, M.N. (1996). The concept of the third party in arbitration: A comparative analytical and application study of the principle of relativity of the effect of arbitration for the third party. Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabia.