REGIONAL GOVERNMENT AUTONOMY IN INDONESIA: THE AMBIGUITY OF THE FEDERALISM OR REPUBLIC MODEL

Muhammad Mutawalli Mukhlis; Maskun; Muhammad Saleh Tajuddin; Dewi Andriani; Rizal Muchtasar; Ahmad Masum

doi:10.33102/mjsl.vol13no1.760

Authors

Muhammad Mutawalli Mukhlis Syariah dan Ekonomi Bisnis Islam, Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam Negeri Majene, Majene, Indonesia https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4286-6964
Maskun Faculty of Law, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia
Muhammad Saleh Tajuddin Faculty of Ushuluddin and Philosophy, Universitas Islam Negeri Alauddin Makassar, Indonesia
Dewi Andriani Faculty of Law, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia
Rizal Muchtasar Faculty of Law, Hasanuddin University, Makassar, Indonesia
Ahmad Masum Sultan Haji Hassanal Bolkiah Faculty of Law, Universiti Islam Sultan Sharif Ali, Bandar Seri Begawan, Brunei Darussalam

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.33102/mjsl.vol13no1.760

Keywords:

Republican, autonomy, regional government, delegation

Abstract

Over the years, there has been ongoing debates regarding the optimal role and status of regional governments as representatives of the central government, with a primary focus on the degree of autonomy afforded to local governments. This paper provides a critical analysis of the issues surrounding regional government autonomy within a republican framework. Central to this examination are significant concerns about the relationship between the central government and regional administrations, extending down to the grassroots level, as well as the dynamics between regional governments and village-level administrations. The research methodology employed in this study is doctrinal, scrutinising the Constitution of Indonesia and other relevant legal frameworks concerning regional governance. The findings reveal that constitutional provisions in Indonesia serve as a basis for unwarranted central government interference in regional affairs. Despite the constitutional mandate to free regional governance from central control and allow for independent regional management, practical and ideological challenges persist. The results indicate that while the Indonesian Constitution aims to provide regional governments with significant autonomy, in practice, the central government retains substantial control over regional affairs. This central interference often undermines the effectiveness and independence of regional administrations, particularly at the village level. The study highlights the need for a clearer delineation of powers to enable more effective regional governance. In conclusion, the paper asserts that the republican governmental system inherently supports the existence of regional administrations capable of independent operation. However, constitutional constraints pose significant challenges to achieving a fully autonomous regional governance system. The study proposes that further delegation and realisation of broad and independent regional management should be entrusted to regional governments through comprehensive decentralisation. Nonetheless, achieving this remains challenging due to the prevailing dualistic paradigm of regional autonomy. The paper calls for a more robust framework to ensure true autonomy for regional governments, involving a significant shift in both legal and administrative practices to reduce central government interference and enhance local governance capabilities.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Abdullah, D. (2016). Hubungan pemerintah pusat dengan pemerintah daerah. Jurnal Hukum Positum, 1(1), 83–93.

Abrianto, B. O., Ibrahim, F., & Nugraha, X. (2020). Reformulating the concept of state principles based on ideological and technocratic strategic as a sustainable development direction. Law Reform, 16(1), 112-126. https://doi.org/10.14710/lr.v16i1.30309

Agboola, T. O. (2016). The challenges of state/local government creation in Nigeria: A critical analysis. International Journal of Politics and Good Governance, 7(7.1), 1-18.

Agustino, L. (2011). Democratisation in Indonesia: From the new order to reformasi. Jebat: Malaysian Journal of History, Politics, & Strategic Studies, 38(1), 171.

Albar, R. A. H., Siregar, E. F. N., & Al Asyari, H. (2023). Nurturing tomorrow’s jurists: Rethinking the Indonesian constitutional court’s clerkship system through a comparative lens. Journal of Indonesian Legal Studies, 8(2), 975–1018. https://doi.org/10.15294/jils.v8i2.74043

Aridhayandi, M. R. (2018). Peran pemerintah daerah dalam pelaksanaan pemerintahan yang baik (good governance) dibidang pembinaan dan pengawasan indikasi geografis. Jurnal Hukum & Pembangunan, 48(4), 883–902.

Arifin, F. (2024). Distribusi kewenangan pusat dan daerah dalam bingkai otonomi daerah di Indonesia. Justicia Sains: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 9(1), 34 – 46. https://doi.org/10.24967/jcs.v9i1.3226

Aritonang, D. M. (2018). Pola distribusi urusan pemerintahan daerah pasca berlakunya undang-undang nomor 23 tahun 2014 tentang pemerintahan daerah. Jurnal Legislasi Indonesia, 13(1), 41–51.

Asshiddiqie, J. (2001). Pengantar pemikiran tentang rancangan perubahan undang-undang dasar negara kesatuan republik Indonesia. Jakarta: The Habibie Center.

Bedner, A. W., & Van Huis, S. (2008). The return of the native in Indonesian law indigenous communities in Indonesian legislation. Bijdragen Tot de Taal-, Land- En Volkenkunde, 164(2–3), 165–193. https://doi.org/10.1163/22134379-90003655

Benda, H. J. (1956). The beginnings of the Japanese occupation of java. The Far Eastern Quarterly, 15(4), 541–560. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.2307/2941923

Bhagwan, V., & Bhushan, V. (2010). World constitution-a comparative study: Political science. New Delhi: Sterling Publishers Pvt. Ltd.

Borschberg, P. (2021). The dutch east india company (VOC) in southeast asia. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Asian History. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190277727.013.550

Brodjonegoro, B., & Asanuma, S. (2000). Regional autonomy and fiscal decentralization in democratic Indonesia. Hitotsubashi Journal of Economics, 41(2), 111–122.

Carnegie, P. (2020). Reorganizing constitutional power in Indonesia: The politics of reform. Journal of Politics and Democratization, 4(4), 53–70.

Cools, M., & Chirtoaca, D. (2017). “Local and regional democracy in Switzerland”. Congress of Local and Regional Authorities. https://rm.coe.int/local-and-regional-democracy-in-switzerland/1680750d61

Crouch, H. (2010). Struggles over regional government. In Political Reform in Indonesia after Soeharto. ISEAS–Yusof Ishak Institute.

Dalhatu, S. (2006). Essays on local government administration: Fostering better service delivery, record keeping, accountability and empowerment at the local government. Benchmark Publishers.

Down, N. (2016). Indonesian nationalism and postcolonial colonialism: Enduring legacies for papua. In E-International Relations.

Fakih, F. (2017). Institutional Reforms of the Guided Democracy (1957-1965). Lembaran Sejarah, 10(1), 96–113. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.22146/lembaran-sejarah.23656

Farih, A. (2019). Konsistensi nahdlatul ulama’ dalam mempertahankan pancasila dan kedaulatan negara kesatuan republik Indonesia di tengah wacana negara Islam. Jurnal Politik Walisongo, 1(1), 1–20.

Fatimah, M., Haryanto, H., & Dwi Retnandari, N. (2024). Central-Local Government Relations in Regional Planning and Budgeting in Indonesia: Between Autonomy and Control. Policy & Governance Review, 8(2), 131. https://doi.org/10.30589/pgr.v8i2.922

Fatoni, A. (2020). Fiscal decentralization dilemma in Indonesia: Between corruption accountability and probability at local levels. Jurnal Bina Praja: Journal of Home Affairs Governance, 12(1), 103–112.

Fauzi, A. (2019). Otonomi daerah dalam kerangka mewujudkan penyelenggaraan pemerintahan daerah yang baik. Jurnal Spektrum Hukum, 16(1), 119–136.

Gamkhar, S., & Pickerill, J. M. (2012). The state of American federalism 2011–2012: A fend for yourself and activist form of bottom-up federalism. Publius: The Journal of Federalism, 42(3), 357–386.

Grataridarga, N., Mardiati, W., & Putri, N. R. (2022). Digitization of the 17th and 18th Centuries’ Dutch East India Company (VOC) Archives for The Archives’ Preservation. Proceedings, 83(60), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.3390/proceedings2022083060

Hariyanto, H. (2020). Hubungan kewenangan antara pemerintah pusat dan pemerintah daerah berdasarkan negara kesatuan republik Indonesia. Volksgeist: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum Dan Konstitusi, 3(2), 99–115. https://doi.org/10.24090/volksgeist.v3i2.4184

Hatchard, J., Ndulo, M., & Slinn, P. (2004). Comparative constitutionalism and good governance in the commonwealth: An eastern and southern African perspective. Cambridge University Press.

Hayden, B. Y. R. (1924). Political progress in the netherlands indies. The Atlantic, 184(3), 401–412.

Hestiliani, T. (2019). Secentralisatie wet van nederland indies 1903. Istoria, 15(2), 206–215.

Hidayat, S. (2017). Bringing the power back in: Insight into the puzzle of Indonesian decentralisation reform. PCD Journal, 3(1–2), 125–158. https://doi.org/10.22146/pcd.25746

Holzinger, K., Haer, R., Bayer, A., Behr, D. M., & Neupert-Wentz, C. (2019). The constitutionalization of indigenous group rights, traditional political institutions, and customary law. Comparative Political Studies, 52(12), 1775–1809.

Ismoilova, S. (2022). Independence of local government. Indonesian Journal of Law and Economics Review, 14(1), 6–14. https://doi.org/10.21070/ijccd2023865

Jaelani, A. K., & Hayat, M. J. (2022). The proliferation of regional regulation cancellation in Indonesia. Journal of Human Rights, Culture and Legal System, 2(2), 121–138. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.53955/jhcls.v2i3.55

Johansyah. (2018). Pemerintahan daerah dalam sistem otonomi. Solusi, 16(3), 283–292.

Kencana, E. N. (2019). The role of local government in fostering the economic of community: A lesson from tourism development at Nusa Penida islands of Bali. Journal of Tourism, 6(1), 119–129. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.24922/eot.v6i1.47283

Kroeze, R. (2021). Colonial normativity? Corruption in the dutch–Indonesian relationship in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. In Corruption, Empire and Colonialism in the Modern Era (pp. 173–208). Palgrave Macmillan. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-16-0255-9_7

Kusriyah, S. (2016). Politik Hukum penyelenggaraan otonomi daerah dalam perspektif negara kesatuan republik Indonesia. Jurnal Pembaharuan Hukum, 3(1), 1–11.

Legge, J. D., McDivitt, J. F., Leinbach, T. R., Mohamad, G. S., Wolters, O. W., & Adam, A. W. (2025). Growth and impact of the Dutch East India Company. Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/place/Indonesia/Growth-and-impact-of-the-Dutch-East-India-Company

Lekipiouw, S. H. (2020). Konstruksi penataan daerah dan model pembagian urusan pemerintahan. Sasi, 26(4), 557–570.

Magenda, B. D. (2018). Peran Otonomi Dan Konsolidasi Daerah Dalam Penguatan Ketahanan Nasional Di Indonesia. Jurnal Kajian Stratejik Ketahanan Nasional, 1(1), 72–86. http://jurnalpkn.ui.ac.id/index.php/jkskn/article/view/7

Maleke, I. T. (2019). Kewenangan Pelayanan di Bidang Pertanahan dalam Otonomi Daerah Menurut Undang-Undang Nomor 23 Tahun 2014 tentang Otonomi Daerah. Lex Administratum, 6(3), 130-141.

Muhaimin, L. O., Mustafa, L. O. A., & Nasrin. (2023). Menggagas standar tertentu otonomi daerah melalui mahkamah konstitusi. Mimbar Hukum, 35(2), 145–174. https://doi.org/10.22146/mh.v35i2.7045

Mukhlis, M. M. (2023). Negara hukum kedaulatan dan demokrasi (konsepsi teori dan perkembangannya). Pustaka Aksara.

Mukhlis, M. M., Maskun, Ayub, Z. A., Tajuddin, M. S., & Wahab, H. A. (2023). Legislative elections: An overview of closed proportional system. Petita: Jurnal Kajian Ilmu Hukum Dan Syariah, 8(2), 93–109.

Mukhlis, M. M., Maskun, M., Tajudin, M. S., & Paidi, Z. (2024). Regional government according to the 1945 constitution: Ideas refinements and law reform. Journal of Law and Legal Reform, 5(2), 495–530.

Nurcholis, H. (2005). Pengembangan kapasitas pemda: Upaya mewujudkan pemda yang menyejahterakan masyarakat. Jurnal Organisasi Dan Manajemen, 1(1), 45–98.

Nurcholis, H. (2015). Sejarah pemerintahan lokal/daerah di Indonesia. Universitas Terbuka.

Nwabueze, B. O. (1983). Federalism in Nigeria under the presidential constitution. Sweet & Maxwell.

Nwabueze, B. O. (1993). Ideas and Facts in Constitution Making. Spectrum Books.

Odenigwe, G. A. (1977). A new system of local government: Government by the community in the east central state of Nigeria. In the Proceedings of the seminar on divisional administration. Nwamife Publishers.

Otto, J. M. (2015). Indonesian opposition in the colonial municipality: A minahasser in Bandung. Asian Journal of Law and Society, 2(1), 169–193. https://doi.org/10.1017/als.2015.5

Pahrudin. (2019). The role of the merangin regency government through welfare policy in the globalization era. The Journal of Society and Media, 3(2), 216–236. https://doi.org/10.26740/jsm.v3n2.p216-236

Pardosi, R. O. A. G. (2023). Sinergitas pemerintahan pusat dan pemerintahan daerah dalam perumusan kebijakan. Jurnal Legislasi Indonesia, 20(2), 61-75.

Pattipawae, D. R. (2019). Pelaksanaan eksekusi putusan pengadilan tata usaha negara di era otonomi. Sasi, 25(1), 92–106.

Pitono, A. (2012). Asas Dekonsentrasi dan asas tugas pembantuan dalam penyelenggaraan pemerintahan. Jurnal Kebijakan Publik, 3(1), 1-55.

Putra, P. A., Hermana, M. A., & Apriyanto, S. (2020). Implementasi kebijakan otonomi daerah dalam pasal 18 undang-undang dasar 1945 dalam perspektif politik hukum di Indonesia. BATARADARMA Journal (Law Studies), 1(1), 13-23.

Rahmat, A., Warassih, E., & Syamsudin, M. (2023). The existence of nagari in west Sumatra on state policy hegemony. Malaysian Journal of Syariah and Law, 11(2), 310–329. https://doi.org/10.33102/mjsl.vol11no2.452

Ramstedt, C. J. G. H. M. (2009). Decentralization and Regional Autonomy in Indonesia: Implementation and Challenges. ISEAS / IIAS.

Rosadi, O. (2015). Konstitusionalitas pengaturan pemerintahan daerah di Indonesia: Suatu eksperimen yang tidak kunjung selesai. Padjajaran Jurnal Ilmu Hukum (Journal of Law), 2(3), 541–563.

Sabara, A. R. (2022). Regional autonomy in the political system and authority in Indonesia. Diponegoro Law Review, 7(2), 296–311. https://doi.org/10.14710/dilrev.7.2.2022.296-311

Safa’at, M. A. (2015). Sentralisasi dalam UU nomor 23 tahun 2014 tentang pemerintahan daerah. In FGD Inventarisir Persoalan UU, (pp. 1-10). APKASI.

Sahid, A., Amirullah, I., Rahman, A. A., Senaman, A., & Yusriadi, Y. (2020). The role of the government in supporting the duties of local governments in Makassar City. International Journal of Scientific and Technology Research, 9(3), 3774–3777.

Sasaki, N. (1984). Atarashii Chiho Seihu. Ashi Shobo.

Squire, P. (1997). A new order in American politics: A supplement to accompany dynamics of democracy. McGraw-Hill.

Sujatmiko, A., Romadhona, M. K., Keizer, P., & Antons, C. (2024). Regional government according to the 1945 constitution: Ideas refinements and law reform. Journal of Law and Legal Reform, 5(2), 495–530. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.15294/jllr.vol5i1.3125

Sutrisno, E. (2015). Gubernur sebagai wakil pemerintah pusat dalam sistem pemerintahan daerah di negara kesatuan republik Indonesia. Jurnal Desentralisasi, 13(1), 32–46.

Suzor, N. (2020). A constitutional moment: How we might reimagine platform governance. Computer Law and Security Review, 36, 105381. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.clsr.2019.105381

Tomasson, G. (1970). Indonesia economic stabilization. Finance & Development. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.5089/9781616353018.022.A008

Usman, S. (2001). Indonesia’ s decentralization policy: Initial experiences and emerging problems. East Asian Bureau of Economic Research.

Varkkey, H. (2012). Patronage politics and natural resources: a historical case study of Southeast Asia and Indonesia. Asian Profile, 40(5), 438–448.

Wahyono, E. (2009). Desentralisasi dan otonomi daerah di jawa pada masa pemerintahan Hindia Belanda: Perubahan pemerintahan daerah berdasarkan bestuurshervormingswet 1922. (Doctoral dissertation). Universitas Indonesia.

Widodo, J. (2003). Good governance: Telaah dari dimensi akuntabilitas dan kontrol birokrasi pada era desentralisasi dan otonomi daerah. Insan Cendekia.